Property Tax Case Studies: Incorporation, SDLT, ATED and CGT
Cases reviewed by Hussein Bhaiji FCCA CTA, Managing Partner. Last updated November 2026.
Property taxes overlap, and the expensive mistakes usually happen in the gaps: ATED returns nobody filed, SDLT reclaims that should never be made, capital gains checks built on assumptions, and buy-to-let incorporations priced on the wrong rules. These five real cases show how our Chartered Tax Advisers handled each one.
In one, we showed HMRC its view of the facts was wrong. In another, we persuaded HMRC to cancel penalties for returns that had genuinely been missed. One involved telling a client not to make a claim at all. The fourth shows what careful planning can save before a property portfolio moves into a company. The fifth is a landlord who came forward under the Let Property Campaign before HMRC found five years of undeclared rent.
Three years of ATED relief declaration returns filed, and £4,800 of penalties cancelled
The issue. A developer held completed but unsold houses, a show home and a site with an existing house awaiting demolition, all held in a limited company and each worth more than £500,000. It had never filed an Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings return, because property developers’ relief (section 138 Finance Act 2013) reduced the charge to nil and nobody thought a nil charge needed a return. HMRC assessed penalties across three years totalling £4,800, with no tax at stake at all.
What we did. Relief from ATED has to be claimed on a relief declaration return, filed by 30 April for properties held on 1 April (or within 30 days of acquiring one later in the year, unless a return for the same relief is already in for that period). One return covers any number of properties in the same relief category, which makes it cheap to do and easy to forget. Because there is never any money to pay, the deadline generates no cash-flow prompt and drops off the compliance calendar entirely. We filed the outstanding returns, appealed the penalties on the basis of reasonable excuse under paragraph 23 of Schedule 55 Finance Act 2009 and, in the alternative, asked for a special reduction under paragraph 16 given the nil liability and the client’s otherwise clean record. We then set up a standing March reminder, tied to the company’s register of properties held as stock, so the return goes in before 30 April.
The outcome. Penalties of £4,800 cancelled and the filing position brought up to date. We also flagged that the next valuation date is 1 April 2027. From 2028/29 any property still held may sit in a higher band, which matters if relief is ever lost, for example if a house is let or occupied before sale.
£43,000 SDLT reclaim on an ‘uninhabitable’ house: why we advised against the stamp duty refund
The issue. A client bought a run-down house for £850,000, paid SDLT at residential rates including the 5% higher rates surcharge for additional dwellings, and was then approached by a reclaim firm offering to recover £43,000 on the basis that the property was uninhabitable and should have been taxed at non-residential rates. The fee was contingent, so it looked like a free bet.
What we did. It is not a free bet, because the client signs the amended return and carries the risk. The Court of Appeal decision in Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799, handed down on 27 June 2025, settled that disrepair capable of being cured does not stop a property being suitable for use as a dwelling within section 116 Finance Act 2003. Rewiring, replumbing, a new kitchen, damp and no heating are not enough. The Court of Appeal approved the Upper Tribunal’s test, which looks at the fundamental characteristics of the building at the effective date as a matter of fact and degree. A property can still fall outside the residential rates in an exceptional case such as P N Bewley Ltd v HMRC [2019] UKFTT 65 (TC), where asbestos meant the bungalow could not be worked on without risk to those doing the work, but a long list of repairs is not enough. We read the surveyor’s report, found nothing beyond curable disrepair, and advised against the claim.
The outcome. No claim was made. Had it gone in, we would expect HMRC to have recovered the £43,000, with interest and a penalty, and the reclaim firm would have been long gone.
HMRC CGT check closed: private residence relief applied and no 60-day return was due
The issue. A client sold a property and HMRC opened a capital gains tax compliance check based on an assumed gain, with a potential CGT exposure of almost £140,000. HMRC was also proceeding on the basis that a 60-day UK property return should have been filed.
What we did. We reviewed the full ownership and occupation history in detail. While the client had not occupied the property for the entire ownership period, part of the period qualified for private residence relief (section 222 TCGA 1992), and the periods of non-occupation were covered by the deemed occupation rules in section 223. We wrote to HMRC explaining that full private residence relief applied, and that, as no capital gains tax was due, no 60-day reporting obligation arose either. That exception is available to UK residents only: a non-resident has to file within 60 days of completion whether or not any tax is payable. See our tax services for non-UK residents.
The outcome. HMRC closed the check without requesting any further evidence. The client paid no CGT and filed nothing further. Our team includes professionals who have worked inside HMRC, so we know how HMRC builds and tests a case like this, and we answer it on those terms.
Buy-to-let portfolio transferred to a limited company with £143,000 of CGT deferred under section 162 incorporation relief
The issue. A Manchester landlord owned eight flats in his own name, worth £1.6m with mortgages of £700,000, and managed them himself, spending well over 20 hours a week on lettings, repairs and tenants. Since section 24 Finance (No. 2) Act 2015 (sections 272A and 274A ITTOIA 2005) restricted his mortgage interest relief to a basic rate tax reduction, he was paying higher rate tax on profit he did not have in cash. From April 2027 property income has its own rates: Finance Act 2026 sets them at 22%, 42% and 47% for 2027/28, and Budget 2026 proposes 24%, 44% and 49% in the Finance Bill now before Parliament, so the gap widens further. These rates apply in England and Northern Ireland; the Scottish Parliament and the Senedd set property income rates for Scotland and Wales. Transferring the portfolio to a limited company looked like the answer, until his previous adviser estimated capital gains tax of £143,000 and stamp duty land tax of £185,750 on the move.
What we did. The capital gains tax turned on whether his letting was a business. In Ramsay v HMRC [2013] UKUT 226 (TCC) the Upper Tribunal accepted that the level of personal work involved in running a property can make letting a business, so we documented his hours and activities and transferred the whole portfolio as a going concern in exchange for shares. Section 162 TCGA 1992 then deducts the gain of about £600,000 from the base cost of the shares, deferring it until the shares are sold, so no capital gains tax was payable. The mortgages were business liabilities, so under extra-statutory concession D32 HMRC does not treat the company taking them over as consideration that reduces the relief (HMRC Capital Gains Manual CG65745). With no tax due, no 60-day UK property return was needed.
For stamp duty land tax the company pays on market value (section 53 Finance Act 2003), but eight dwellings transferred in a single transaction are treated as non-residential property under section 116(7), so non-residential rates applied instead of residential rates plus the 5% higher rates surcharge, which a company pays on almost every residential purchase. His letting was not a partnership, so we did not claim partnership relief under Schedule 15 Finance Act 2003, and we advised against creating one shortly before the transfer.
The outcome. Capital gains tax of £143,000 deferred, stamp duty land tax of £69,500 instead of £185,750, and the mortgage interest now deducted in full against the company’s profits. For transfers on or after 6 April 2026, incorporation relief no longer applies automatically. It must be claimed in or with the Self Assessment return, by the first anniversary of the 31 January after the tax year of transfer (HMRC Capital Gains Manual CG65735). We build the claim into every incorporation we handle.
Five years of undeclared rent put right under the Let Property Campaign
The issue. A higher-rate taxpayer, paid through PAYE, had let two flats since 2019 and had never told HMRC about the rent. He assumed it was dealt with because tax came out of his salary. By late 2025 the rents for 2019/20 to 2023/24 came to about £86,000 and he had never registered for Self Assessment. Where a landlord has failed to register, HMRC can go back up to 20 years, and he wanted to put it right before HMRC found the income itself.
What we did. We rebuilt the rental accounts for each year from his bank statements, the letting agent’s statements and his invoices. Expenses he had never counted (agent’s fees, insurance, repairs and the replacement of furniture and appliances under section 311A ITTOIA 2005) brought the taxable profit for the five years down to £49,800. We notified HMRC under the Let Property Campaign before it had contacted him, which made the disclosure unprompted, and sent the disclosure and the payment together within the 90 days HMRC allows. We registered him for Self Assessment at the same time, so his 2024/25 return was filed by the normal deadline.
The outcome. Tax of £19,920, interest of £2,650 and penalties of £2,232. Because he came forward first and the failure was not deliberate, the penalty for failing to notify was at the bottom of the range the law allows (Schedule 41 Finance Act 2008): nothing for the most recent year, 10% for the two years before it and 20% for the two oldest, where HMRC limits the reduction because of the delay. Had HMRC written to him first, the minimum on every year more than 12 months late would have been 20%. HMRC accepted the disclosure without opening an enquiry.
Uninhabitable property and stamp duty: three questions these cases raise
Can I get a stamp duty refund on an uninhabitable property?
Only if, at completion, the building was not suitable for use as a dwelling, rarer than reclaim firms suggest. The question is not whether a property is uninhabitable in everyday terms but whether, at the effective date, it lacks the fundamental characteristics of a dwelling: the Upper Tribunal’s test, approved in Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799. Remediable defects, even complete rewiring and a new boiler, did not take the house in that case out of the residential rates, and actual use as a dwelling is a very strong indication of suitability. The claim is yours, so if it fails, the tax, interest and any penalty fall on you.
Is there a mixed-use stamp duty loophole?
No. The non-residential rates, usually lower, apply when the land bought includes land that is not residential property (section 55(1B) Finance Act 2003), but the garden or grounds of a house are residential property (section 116(1)(b)). In Hyman v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 185 the buyers argued that paddocks and a stable yard were not part of the grounds. The tribunals held that they were, and the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeals: land does not cease to be residential property merely because the occupier could do without it. A genuine commercial element, such as a shop below a flat, is different, and we check it on the facts.
Is multiple dwellings relief still available?
No. Multiple dwellings relief was abolished for transactions with an effective date on or after 1 June 2024 (section 7 Finance (No. 2) Act 2024), except under a contract entered into on or before 6 March 2024 that has not since been varied, assigned or sub-sold, or completed by exercising an option. A different rule helped in the buy-to-let case above, and it remains: six or more separate dwellings bought in a single transaction, as the eight flats were, are treated as not being residential property (section 116(7) Finance Act 2003). The non-residential rates then apply, instead of the residential rates and, where due, the 5% higher rates surcharge.
Could we do the same for you?
Every case above turned on the same thing: getting the technical position right before HMRC, or a reclaim firm, decided it for the client. We are Chartered Certified Accountants and Chartered Tax Advisers, our team includes professionals who have worked inside HMRC, and our partners have built their own businesses from nothing to over £1m in turnover. In most cases the tax we save exceeds the fee we charge.
Related services: Capital gains tax reporting · ATED returns · Tax advisory services · Accountants for landlords · Construction and property VAT case studies.
What clients say about Merit on Google
“They flag things before we’ve even thought to ask, which is something we’ve never experienced with an accountant before.”
Farz B., Google review
“They quickly understand complex matters, explain them in straightforward terms and provide practical, commercially sound solutions tailored to our needs.”
Zyba K., Google review
“Every year they are prompt and responsive, even reminding us when our filings and VAT reports are due.”
DanRaw Stores, Google review
“They are a highly professional, knowledgeable team and a true pleasure to work with.”
Liana T., Google review
“The team go above and beyond to deliver the best service and are always striving to find ways to improve the business position.”
Vardan F., Google review